Table of contents
1.
Introduction
2.
Understanding Polyfilling
2.1.
What is Polyfilling?
2.2.
Syntax
2.3.
Purpose of Polyfilling
2.4.
When to use Polyfilling?
2.5.
Impact on Performance with Polyfilling
3.
Understanding Transpiling
3.1.
What is Transpiling?
3.2.
Syntax
3.3.
Purpose of Transpiling
3.4.
When to use Transpiling?
3.5.
Impact on Performance with Transpiling
4.
Polyfilling Vs Transpiling
5.
Limitations of Polyfilling 
5.1.
Dependency on Environment
5.2.
Performance Impact
5.3.
Partial Compatibility
5.4.
Browser Support
5.5.
Limited Features
6.
Limitations of Transpiling
6.1.
Language Limitations
6.2.
Performance Overhead
6.3.
Tool Dependency
6.4.
Compatibility Caveats
6.5.
Learning Curve
7.
Frequently Asked Questions
7.1.
What are some popular Polyfill libraries?
7.2.
Can I Transpile other languages, not just JavaScript?
7.3.
Can I use Polyfills and Transpilers together?
8.
Conclusion
Last Updated: Mar 27, 2024
Medium

Difference Between Polyfilling and Transpiling

Career growth poll
Do you think IIT Guwahati certified course can help you in your career?

Introduction

Polyfilling and transpiling are essential strategies in modern web development that provide distinct challenges. Polyfilling addresses absent features in older browsers while transpiling streamlines code for cross-version harmony. Both techniques contribute to a seamless and up-to-date web development landscape.

Difference between Polyfilling and Transpiling

Let's see how these tools help our code fit in everywhere.

Understanding Polyfilling

Imagine you have a cool new game, but some of your friends have old game consoles that can't play it. To help them join the fun, you create special items that make the game work on their old consoles too. This way, everyone can enjoy the game, even if their consoles are not as advanced.

In the world of coding, this idea is called "Polyfilling." When we create new and fancy things in code, some older computers or browsers might not understand them. Polyfills are like those special items you made for your friends. They're bits of code that add missing parts, so even old computers can use the new stuff.

What is Polyfilling?

Polyfilling is the process of using code to fill the gaps in a web browser's native support for certain JavaScript features. It allows developers to bring new functionalities to older browsers that wouldn't otherwise understand or support those features.It lets older browsers understand and use new tricks in JavaScript that they didn't know before. This way, developers can make their websites work well for everyone, no matter which browser they're using.

Imagine you have a toy that needs new batteries, but the old ones don't fit. A polyfill is like finding a way to make those new batteries work in the old toy. In the coding world, it's when we add special code to make modern things work on older computers or browsers. It's like making sure your favourite game can be played on both the newest and the oldest game consoles.

Syntax

The syntax of polyfilling involves writing additional code to provide missing features in older environments. 

For Example,

if (!Array.prototype.includes) {
    // Polyfill code goes here
}


Explanation

The if (!Array.prototype.includes) condition checks if the Array.prototype.includes method is not already defined in the browser's JavaScript environment. If it's not defined, that means the browser doesn't support the method.

In this case, a polyfill would be used to provide the missing functionality. A polyfill is a piece of code that adds the missing method to the browser's native JavaScript objects. Inside the if block, you would place the code that defines the includes method for arrays. This code will typically involve iterating through the array and comparing each element to the target element, returning true if a match is found and false otherwise.

By adding this polyfill code, you're ensuring that the includes method is available and functional even in browsers that originally lacked support for it. This allows you to use modern code and features across a wider range of browsers while maintaining consistent behaviour.

In essence, this example demonstrates how polyfilling helps bridge the gap between modern code and older browser environments by adding missing features where needed.

Steps

Let’s discuss the steps to be taken for the implementation.

Write the Polyfill 

Write the code that emulates the missing feature. This code replicates the functionality of the feature for environments that lack native support.

Implement the Polyfill

Place the polyfill code inside the feature detection block. This ensures that the polyfill is only applied if the feature is absent.

Load the Polyfill

To load the polyfill script, you can use a <script> tag in your HTML file. Link to an external polyfill file or include the code directly on the page.

<script src="path-to-polyfill.js"> </script>


Test and Verify

Thoroughly test your code in different browsers to ensure that the polyfill works as intended.

Purpose of Polyfilling

The purpose of polyfilling is to make sure that our new and cool code works on older computers and web browsers. When we use new code tricks, some older browsers might not understand them. Polyfills are like little helpers that we add to our code. These helpers make sure that our new code works on those older browsers. It's like allowing everyone to enjoy the game, no matter how old their browsers are.

Imagine you have a super fun game, but some older game consoles can't play it because they're missing some unique parts. Polyfilling is like adding those missing parts to the old consoles so they can play the game too.

When to use Polyfilling?

You should use polyfilling when you want to use new and cool features in your code, but you also want your code to work on older computers and web browsers. It's like if you have a fun toy that needs special batteries, but your old remote control doesn't fit. You would use a special adapter to make the toy work with the old remote control. Similarly, when your code has new things that some older web browsers don't understand, you use polyfills to add extra code so that even the old browsers can understand and run your new features. It's a way to include everyone in the fun, no matter what kind of technology they're using.

Impact on Performance with Polyfilling

Polyfilling can impact performance by adding extra code to a web page. This additional code might slow down the page's loading time and execution speed. Browsers need to process both the original code and the polyfill code, which can result in a delay in displaying the content and responding to user interactions.

It's like carrying extra luggage while walking, you might not move as quickly. Browsers have to work harder to understand the extra code, which can cause a delay in showing the website and making it work smoothly.

Understanding Transpiling

Transpiling is like having a magical language converter. Imagine you have two friends who speak different languages. You can only talk in your language, but you want both friends to understand your story. Transpiling is like having a translator who listens to your story, translates it into your friends' language, and then they can enjoy the story too. Similarly, in coding, transpiling changes your code into a version that more computers can understand, making sure your ideas work for everyone.

What is Transpiling?

Transpiling, short for "source-to-source compiling," is a process in software development where a tool converts code from one programming language (source language) into another programming language (target language). Unlike traditional compilation, which transforms high-level code directly into machine code, transpilation focuses on converting code from one human-readable language to another, usually with the goal of adapting it to a specific environment, platform, or compatibility requirement.

Transpilers are commonly used when developers want to write code using the features and syntax of a modern programming language but need the resulting code to be executed in an older or different environment that may not support those features. The transpiler analyzes the source code and generates equivalent code in the target language, ensuring that the functionality and logic remain the same while accommodating the constraints of the target environment.

Example

For example, if a developer writes code using the latest JavaScript features but needs the code to work on older web browsers that don't support those features, they can use a JavaScript transpiler to convert the modern code into an older version of JavaScript that is compatible with those browsers. This enables developers to leverage the benefits of modern programming constructs without sacrificing compatibility.

In essence, transpiling acts as an intermediary step that allows developers to bridge the gap between different programming languages and environments, making their code accessible and functional across various platforms.

Syntax

Let's say you have Python code written using a newer feature called the "walrus operator," which assigns a value to a variable as part of an expression. 

But you want to use this code in an older version of Python that doesn't support the walrus operator. You could use a transpiler-like approach to transform the code by replacing instances of the walrus operator with equivalent code that older Python versions can understand.

Original Python code using the walrus operator (Python 3.8+):

while (input_value := input("Enter a value:")) != "quit":
    print("You entered:", input_value)


Transpiled version for older Python (Python 3.7 or below):

while True:
    input_value = input("Enter a value:")
    if input_value == "quit":
        break
    print("You entered:", input_value)


In this example, the transpilation-like process involves converting the code with the walrus operator into an equivalent form that older Python versions can interpret.

However, it's important to note that Python doesn't typically undergo extensive transpilation like JavaScript does. Python versions tend to be backward compatible, and the need for transpilation is relatively rare compared to languages with more rapid syntax changes.

Steps

Let’s discuss the steps to be taken for the implementation.

Write Modern Code 

Write your code using the latest language features without worrying about browser compatibility.

Transpile the Code

Use the transpiler's command-line interface to transpile your code. For example:

npx babel input.js --out-file output.js

Output

The transpiler generates an output file (e.g., output.js) with the modern code converted to an older version.

Use the Transpiled Code

Link the transpiled code (output file) in your HTML, just like you would with any other script.

<script src="output.js"></script>


Testing and Verification

Thoroughly test the transpiled code across different browsers and environments to ensure compatibility.

Remember that different transpilers might have variations in their setup and usage. The above steps provide a general idea of how transpiling works, but always refer to the documentation of the specific transpiler you're using for accurate syntax and instructions.

Purpose of Transpiling

Transpiling serves the purpose of enabling code written in a modern programming language with advanced features to be transformed into code that works in an older or different version. It's like translating a conversation between two people who understand different languages.

In programming, different environments or platforms might understand languages differently. Transpilers help by translating the code's syntax and structure into a version that fits the requirements of the target environment. This ensures that the code can run smoothly on systems that might not fully support the original language's latest features.

It is like converting a cool new dance into an older dance that everyone knows. In programming, it means changing modern code into an older version of code so that it can be understood and used by older computers or systems. This helps make sure your code can work on different machines, even if they don't understand the latest "dance moves" of programming languages.

For instance, if you've written code using the latest version of a language, but you need it to work on older systems, a transpiler can convert the code into a version that those systems can comprehend. This way, you can make use of modern language conveniences while ensuring your code can operate effectively across different setups.

When to use Transpiling?

Use transpiling when you have written your code in a new, fancy programming language with cool features, but you need it to work on older computers or systems that might not understand those new features. Transpiling helps you change your code into an older version of the language so that everyone can understand and use it, like telling a story in a simple way so that both kids and adults can enjoy it.You should consider using transpiling when you've written code in a modern programming language with advanced features, but you need that code to work on platforms or environments that only understand older versions of the language or even a different language altogether. 

Transpiling comes in handy when you want to maintain compatibility across different systems while still benefiting from the capabilities of the modern language you initially used.

Impact on Performance with Transpiling

Using transpiling can have an impact on performance, but it's not always a negative impact. When you transpile code from one language to another, there might be some overhead introduced during the translation process. This can make the code run slightly slower compared to writing it directly in the target language.

Additionally, the transpiled code might not take full advantage of certain optimizations that would be possible if the code were originally written in the target language. This could result in the transpiled code being less efficient in terms of memory usage or execution speed.

However, the impact on performance can vary. In some cases, the performance difference might be negligible, especially if the transpiler is well-optimised and the translation involves only minor adjustments. On the other hand, if the transpilation involves complex transformations, the performance impact might be more noticeable.

In general, while there might be a trade-off between convenience and performance when using transpilation, the benefits of having code that is compatible with a wider range of platforms or environments often outweigh the performance impact, especially when maintaining cross-system compatibility is a high priority.

Polyfilling Vs Transpiling

Let’s discuss the differences between Polyfilling and Transpiling.

Aspect Polyfilling Transpiling
Purpose To provide modern features to older environments To adapt code to different language versions
Usage Mainly for adding missing functionality Mainly for compatibility and language features
Scenario When browser lacks support for a feature When targeting older language versions
Changes Adds new functionality to existing environment Adjusts syntax and structure for new version
Example Adding fetch() support to older browsers Converting ES6 JavaScript to ES5 for browsers
Impact Adds more code and can slow down execution Can introduce minor performance overhead
Dependencies Typically standalone, specific to functionality Can involve using external libraries (Babel)
Execution Active during runtime Pre-processes code before runtime execution

Limitations of Polyfilling 

Let’s discuss the limitations of Polyfilling.

Limitations of Polyfilling

Some of them are listed below.

Dependency on Environment

Polyfills are tightly coupled to specific environments, like web browsers. They can't address gaps in functionalities beyond their environment.

Performance Impact

Adding polyfills can increase code size and slow down the execution, especially if the polyfill is complex or handles a large feature gap.

Partial Compatibility

Polyfills might not perfectly replicate missing features, leading to inconsistencies or bugs in certain scenarios.

Browser Support

Users need to keep browsers updated to benefit from polyfills. Older browsers might not support them, limiting their effectiveness.

Limited Features

Complex features that rely on deep language changes might not be feasible to polyfill.

Limitations of Transpiling

Let’s discuss the limitations of Transpiling.

Limitations of Transpiling

Some of them are listed below.

Language Limitations

Transpiling doesn't create new features; it adjusts syntax. If the target language lacks a specific feature, transpiling won't magically add it.

Performance Overhead

Transpiled code might not be as optimised as hand-written code, potentially introducing slight performance overhead.

Tool Dependency

Using transpilers often involves external tools or libraries. This adds complexity and might require updates as language specifications evolve.

Compatibility Caveats

While transpiling, not all language features might have perfect equivalents in the target version, potentially leading to unexpected behaviour.

Learning Curve

Developers need to understand the transpilation process and the nuances of the target language's version they're transpiling to.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are some popular Polyfill libraries?

Examples include "core-js" and "babel-polyfill." These libraries provide sets of Polyfills for various modern JavaScript features.

Can I Transpile other languages, not just JavaScript?

Yes, transpilation is a common technique in software development. It's used in various programming languages to translate code into different versions or languages.

Can I use Polyfills and Transpilers together?

Yes! Combining polyfills and transpilers is common. Transpile your modern code to an older version and then apply polyfills as needed, ensuring your code works smoothly across various browsers.

Conclusion

Polyfilling and transpiling are tools used in coding to solve different problems. Polyfilling helps make new code work on older systems, like giving a modern dance move to an old dance routine. It fills the gaps but might slow things down. Transpiling changes code from a new version of a language to an older version, so it can work everywhere. It's like translating a story so everyone can understand, but it might not capture all the emotions perfectly. Each has its own purpose and limitations, but they both help developers adapt their code to different situations.
 

Refer to our Guided Path to upskill yourself in DSACompetitive ProgrammingJavaScriptSystem Design, and many more! If you want to test your competency in coding, you may check out the mock test series and participate in the contests hosted on Coding Ninjas Studio!

But suppose you have just started your learning process and are looking for questions from tech giants like Amazon, Microsoft, Uber, etc. For placement preparations, you must look at the problemsinterview experiences, and interview bundles.

We wish you Good Luck! 

Happy Learning!

Live masterclass